Peanut Butter Buckeye Ice Cream

Leave it to me to start an ice cream blog in winter. But as far as I’m concerned, every season is ice cream season. Blizzard winds brought over nine inches of snow in one day to my hometown, where I spent Christmas. Being snowed in at my Mom’s left a lot of time for ice cream making and my first post here highlights one of the flavors I made over Christmas.

Several years ago, my sister-in-law from Ohio introduced me to chocolate-coated peanut butter candies shaped to resemble the nuts from the state’s official tree, the buckeye. Now Christmas isn’t Christmas without buckeyes (and the grumpiness caused by my day-long effort of making 12 or so dozen).

Since I had a massive bowl of buckeye dough anyway, I thought I might as well use some for buckeye-inspired ice cream. The result was velvety-thick peanut butter ice cream studded with tiny buckeye balls. The mini buckeyes stay soft while a swirl of melted chocolate hardens and flakes on contact with the ice cream during the last minute or so of churning in the machine (in Italian, this is called stracciatella), representing buckeye candy’s chocolate coating.

If you don’t want to make buckeye dough (and I wouldn’t blame you if you don’t, have I mentioned the grumpiness?), this ice cream would be plenty tasty without the addition of mini buckeyes.


Buckeye Ice Cream

by Tracy Rimdzius

I poured 5 ounces of melted 51% cocoa Perugina chocolate into the almost finished ice cream while churning. I added about 1/2 cup mini buckeye balls (recipe here, only a small fraction of which is needed for a 1/2 cup buckeye yield).



  1. Kathie

    Tracy – what a perfect Christmas icecream!! Buckeye’s have been in my family for as long as I remember and are the first cookies to disappear! Bet the ice cream was just as good!

    • Thanks for visiting, Kathie! I love buckeyes too. The first year my sister-in-law brought them to our Christmas get together, I don’t think anyone else got one. I must’ve eaten two dozen of them myself.

      Making them isn’t exactly hard, it just takes a long time–I usually watch a movie while I roll them. I was glad to have another use for a little of the dough. I realized I had an extra pint of the ice cream in the freezer after we got home from our Christmas vacation and even though it was a month old, it was still very tasty.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: